Skip to content
San Diego Post

San Diego Post

Your Pulse on Local Stories and National News

Connect with Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
Primary Menu
  • Local News
  • National News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Health
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Local News

Court says looking at GoogleMaps costs $158: California cracks down on drivers

Jacob Shelton June 5, 2025

Share this:

  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
(Image Credit: IMAGN)

May 17, 2022; Columbus, Ohio, USA; State Highway Patrol trooper Kevin Riley issues a speeding ticket along I-270 near Easton Tuesday, May 17, 2022. Mandatory Credit: Doral Chenoweth-The Columbus Dispatch News Excessive Speed

Los Angeles, California – A state appeals court ruled Tuesday that simply holding a phone to look at a map while driving is a violation of California’s hands-free law, even if the driver isn’t tapping, swiping, or otherwise manipulating the device.

The decision by the Sixth District Court of Appeal adds legal clarity—and legal risk—for millions of drivers who have come to rely on smartphone navigation. According to the ruling, the Legislature intended for the law to apply broadly, encompassing the full spectrum of distractions modern mobile devices can cause. “Allowing a driver to hold a phone and view a mapping application, even if not touching the phone’s screen, would be contrary to the Legislature’s intent,” the court wrote.

The case originated when authorities ticketed Nathaniel Gabriel Porter for holding his phone in his left hand while following directions from a GPS app. Porter challenged the $158 fine, arguing that he wasn’t “operating” the device as defined by law—he was merely looking at it.

Initially, Porter won. A judge in Santa Clara County’s appellate division ruled in his favor, determining that “operating” a phone required some form of active manipulation. Just holding the phone and observing the screen, the court said, didn’t rise to that level.

But the Court of Appeal disagreed, reversing the decision and reinstating the violation. In its opinion, the court pointed to the 2016 legislative overhaul of the state’s cellphone law, which expanded the definition of “using” a mobile device while driving. Lawmakers had responded to growing concerns about the scope of distracted driving in the smartphone era, emphasizing that cellphones were no longer just for calls or texts but now functioned as “pocket-sized computers.”

That shift prompted lawmakers to write a more expansive law—one aimed not just at how phones are touched or used, but at how they divide a driver’s attention. According to the Assembly’s bill analyses at the time, the revised statute was designed to prohibit the use of a phone “for any purpose” that might cause distraction.

The court’s ruling reaffirms that understanding, effectively barring handheld use of phones even for passive activities like viewing a navigation app. Drivers can still use phones if they’re mounted and operated with a single swipe or tap—but holding the phone, regardless of interaction, is now firmly off-limits.

Related

Continue Reading

Previous: Tesla Loses $152 Billion as Musk-Trump Rift Escalates Over Spending Bill
Next: California DMV warns of surge in fake discount ads and toll text scams

Related Stories

(Image Credit: IMAGN)
  • Local News

California coast on edge after 8.8 quake triggers tsunami alert

Jacob Shelton July 30, 2025
(Image Credit: Getty Images)
  • Local News

‘Director Vinchenzo’ pleads guilty in $13M California fraud

Jacob Shelton July 29, 2025
(Image Credit: IMAGN)
  • Local News

Somali woman lied in 3 countries—Caught in California, sentenced

Jacob Shelton July 29, 2025
(Image Credit: Getty Images)
  • Local News

$10K per car: California border officers let drugs flow freely

Jacob Shelton July 29, 2025
(Image Credit: IMAGN)
  • Local News

2 California medical staffers accused of assaulting ICE agent during arrest

Jacob Shelton July 28, 2025
(Image Credit: IMAGN)
  • Local News

California man charged in $2 Million romance scam using dating apps

Jacob Shelton July 28, 2025

Connect with Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Trending News

California coast on edge after 8.8 quake triggers tsunami alert (Image Credit: IMAGN) 1

California coast on edge after 8.8 quake triggers tsunami alert

July 30, 2025
Machado powers Padres past Mets 7-1 as Soto exits early with injury MLB: New York Mets at San Diego Padres 2

Machado powers Padres past Mets 7-1 as Soto exits early with injury

July 30, 2025
Díaz walks it off as Padres stun Mets 7–6 in wild comeback win MLB: New York Mets at San Diego Padres 3

Díaz walks it off as Padres stun Mets 7–6 in wild comeback win

July 29, 2025
Judge slams Trump’s ICE raids in California after 56,400 arrests (Image Credit: Getty Images) 4

Judge slams Trump’s ICE raids in California after 56,400 arrests

July 29, 2025
California, 20 states sue USDA over demands for SNAP data (Image Credit: IMAGN) 5

California, 20 states sue USDA over demands for SNAP data

July 29, 2025
‘Director Vinchenzo’ pleads guilty in $13M California fraud (Image Credit: Getty Images) 6

‘Director Vinchenzo’ pleads guilty in $13M California fraud

July 29, 2025
Somali woman lied in 3 countries—Caught in California, sentenced (Image Credit: IMAGN) 7

Somali woman lied in 3 countries—Caught in California, sentenced

July 29, 2025

You may have missed

(Image Credit: IMAGN)
  • Local News

California coast on edge after 8.8 quake triggers tsunami alert

Jacob Shelton July 30, 2025
MLB: New York Mets at San Diego Padres
  • Sports

Machado powers Padres past Mets 7-1 as Soto exits early with injury

Jacob Shelton July 30, 2025
MLB: New York Mets at San Diego Padres
  • Sports

Díaz walks it off as Padres stun Mets 7–6 in wild comeback win

Jacob Shelton July 29, 2025
(Image Credit: Getty Images)
  • Politics

Judge slams Trump’s ICE raids in California after 56,400 arrests

Jacob Shelton July 29, 2025

Recent Posts

  • California coast on edge after 8.8 quake triggers tsunami alert
  • Machado powers Padres past Mets 7-1 as Soto exits early with injury
  • Díaz walks it off as Padres stun Mets 7–6 in wild comeback win
  • Local News
  • National News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Health
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
Copyright © 2025 All rights reserved.