In a decisive move aimed at enhancing public safety, the San Diego County Board of Supervisors unanimously voted on Tuesday to advance a proposal that allows for the clearing of homeless encampments during high fire warnings, commonly referred to as red flag warnings. Authored by Supervisor Jim Desmond, the proposal emphasizes the need for proactive measures to prevent fire risks and protect vulnerable populations.
The unanimous directive instructs county staff to prioritize the relocation of individuals from high fire-risk areas while also exploring housing options for those displaced by the encampment cleanings. County staff are expected to present recommendations for improved removal policies within 90 days. Desmond stated:
This proactive approach aims to protect lives, mitigate fire risks, and support vulnerable populations by ensuring they are not left in harm’s way during dangerous fire conditions.
Pointing to recent fires in neighborhoods such as La Jolla, Mission Valley, and Oceanside, Desmond warned of the potential devastation had Santa Ana winds been present, endangering schools and homes in the area. He is incredibly worried about the dangers posed by open flames used for cooking or warmth in encampments.
Supervisor Joel Anderson added weight to the discussion, expressing his concern as a resident of a red-flag fire zone and urging that the public’s safety must come first. “This isn’t about whether you’re compassionate about homelessness or not—this is about whether somebody has the right to burn down your neighborhood and put your life at risk,” he stated.
Supervisor Monica Montgomery Steppe supported the focus on emergency fire warnings but stressed the importance of having safe alternatives for those affected by encampment removals. “There’s nothing that will come before me that doesn’t have that… at least as part of the conversation,” she remarked.
Vice Chair Terra Lawson-Remer acknowledged the work done by Anderson and Desmond, but noted that we shouldn’t use natural disasters as an excuse to criminalize homelessness.
The proposal garnered praise from various residents and officials, including Chief Joe Napier of the Valley Center Fire Protection District, who expressed optimism about the potential for effective coordination between the county Sheriff’s Office, fire department, and code compliance officials to facilitate public safety education.
In contrast, some, like John Brady from Lived Experience Advisers, cautioned that regional anti-camping regulations have merely pushed homeless individuals into even more perilous situations. He advocated for the integration of mobile homes and travel trailers as temporary housing solutions for those in need.
Jessie Schmitte of Alliance San Diego also raised concerns, emphasizing that the issue of homelessness cannot be addressed solely through bans and that expanded housing options are crucial. “San Diego should lead with compassion, not cruelty,” he concluded.
