Skip to content
San Diego Post

San Diego Post

Your Pulse on Local Stories and National News

Connect with Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
Primary Menu
  • Local News
  • National News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Health
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Local News

ACLU slams California Sheriff over ICE transfer—‘Why did it take a year to explain?’

Jacob Shelton March 12, 2025

Share this:

  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
(Image Credit: IMAGN)

(Image Credit: IMAGN) Jun 6, 2021; Sonoma, California, USA; Sonoma County Sheriff’s Deputies patrol the grounds during the Toyota-Save Mart 350 at Sonoma Raceway. Mandatory Credit: Stan Szeto-USA TODAY Sports

San Diego, California – The San Diego County Sheriff’s Office has defended its 2023 transfer of a jail inmate without legal immigration status to Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) custody, asserting the action was legal under California’s sanctuary law, SB 54.

The defense comes after nearly a year of criticism from immigrant rights advocates, including the ACLU, who flagged the transfer as a potential violation of the California Values Act. The case involves a man with a 2002 assault with a deadly weapon conviction.

Sheriff Kelly Martinez’s office, in an email response to KPBS, cited a section of SB 54 that allows transfers when “the individual has been convicted of a felony punishable by imprisonment in the state prison system.”

“The individual did meet the transfer qualifications under Government Code Section 7282.5 Section 2,” spokesperson Kimberly King wrote.

However, this justification conflicts with another section of SB 54, which Martinez has publicly cited. That section permits transfers only if “the individual has been convicted within the past five years of a misdemeanor … or has been convicted within the last 15 years of a felony for 31 specific criminal offenses.”

The 2002 conviction, being 21 years old, falls outside this 15-year timeframe, prompting advocates’ concerns.

The ACLU, in a statement, acknowledged the cited section could justify the transfer but questioned the delay in its disclosure. “We raised this potential SB 54 violation to the San Diego County Sheriff’s Office during last year’s TRUTH Act Forum and never received a response,” the statement read. “Now that there is public attention on this individual’s case, the Sheriff’s Office is denying state laws were violated. SDSO has failed to explain why they took so long to address this matter.”

The conflicting provisions of SB 54 have created confusion. At a May 2024 public forum, advocates highlighted the 2002 conviction’s age as a potential violation. Martinez, while present, did not address these concerns, instead reiterating her interpretation of SB 54, focusing on the 15-year conviction timeframe.

During the forum, Martinez emphasized public safety and noted that other individuals transferred in 2023 had convictions for serious crimes. The section regarding felonies punishable by imprisonment was not mentioned.

Related

Continue Reading

Previous: Dangerous criminals shielded? San Diego board blocks ICE cooperation repeal
Next: California prisons on high alert after rash of inmate murders prompts crackdown

Related Stories

(Image Credit: IMAGN)
  • Local News

California border agents accused of smuggling over 1,150 pounds of drugs

Jacob Shelton July 9, 2025
(Image Credit: IMAGN)
  • Local News

California city sues ex-cop for $600,000 over disability scam

Jacob Shelton July 9, 2025
(Image Credit: IMAGN)
  • Local News

$3.7 Million fraud rocks California’s art insurance industry

Jacob Shelton July 9, 2025
(Image Credit: Getty Images)
  • Local News

California program offers $600 in gift cards to help unhoused residents quit meth

Jacob Shelton July 9, 2025
(Image Credit: IMAGN)
  • Local News

California’s largest school district bans phones for 94,000 students

Jacob Shelton July 9, 2025
(Image Credit: IMAGN)
  • Local News

California family says ex-wife secretly live-streamed 700 hours of home camera footage

Jacob Shelton July 9, 2025

Connect with Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Trending News

California border agents accused of smuggling over 1,150 pounds of drugs (Image Credit: IMAGN) 1

California border agents accused of smuggling over 1,150 pounds of drugs

July 9, 2025
California city sues ex-cop for $600,000 over disability scam (Image Credit: IMAGN) 2

California city sues ex-cop for $600,000 over disability scam

July 9, 2025
$1.2 Billion industry at risk: California cannabis businesses warn of collapse (Image Credit: IMAGN) 3

$1.2 Billion industry at risk: California cannabis businesses warn of collapse

July 9, 2025
California authorities uncover 4-year Chinese espionage operation targeting U.S. Navy (Image Credit: IMAGN) 4

California authorities uncover 4-year Chinese espionage operation targeting U.S. Navy

July 9, 2025
$3.7 Million fraud rocks California’s art insurance industry (Image Credit: IMAGN) 5

$3.7 Million fraud rocks California’s art insurance industry

July 9, 2025
Governor Newsom announces $35 Million to combat impaired driving and expand cannabis safety initiatives (Image Credit: IMAGN) 6

Governor Newsom announces $35 Million to combat impaired driving and expand cannabis safety initiatives

July 9, 2025
California program offers $600 in gift cards to help unhoused residents quit meth (Image Credit: Getty Images) 7

California program offers $600 in gift cards to help unhoused residents quit meth

July 9, 2025

You may have missed

(Image Credit: IMAGN)
  • Local News

California border agents accused of smuggling over 1,150 pounds of drugs

Jacob Shelton July 9, 2025
(Image Credit: IMAGN)
  • Local News

California city sues ex-cop for $600,000 over disability scam

Jacob Shelton July 9, 2025
(Image Credit: IMAGN)
  • National News

$1.2 Billion industry at risk: California cannabis businesses warn of collapse

Jacob Shelton July 9, 2025
(Image Credit: IMAGN)
  • National News

California authorities uncover 4-year Chinese espionage operation targeting U.S. Navy

Jacob Shelton July 9, 2025

Recent Posts

  • California border agents accused of smuggling over 1,150 pounds of drugs
  • California city sues ex-cop for $600,000 over disability scam
  • $1.2 Billion industry at risk: California cannabis businesses warn of collapse
  • Local News
  • National News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Health
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
Copyright © 2025 All rights reserved.